Skip to content
FR

Stainless steel or cast iron griddle: which plate should you pick?

By Charles Updated on 29/10/2026 Analysed Editor's review

Stainless steel or cast iron: on a griddle, the plate material decides how fast heat builds up, how evenly it spreads, how long it holds, and how much time you spend cleaning. Stainless steel reacts quickly and rinses clean with water; enamelled cast iron holds its heat and sears harder, but weighs more and does not like thermal shocks. Neither is better in every case: it depends on what you cook and how much care you are willing to give it. To see every model by fuel and size, our griddle page brings together all the planchas we have reviewed.

Two griddles side by side on a terrace, one with a shiny stainless steel plate and one with a black enamelled cast iron plate, with vegetables and prawns cooking

In short

Go for stainless steel if you want a plate that heats and cools fast, resists rust and needs no special care when cleaning. Go for enamelled cast iron if you want steady heat to sear meat, with a naturally non-stick surface, and you are happy to avoid sudden temperature changes.

Criterion Stainless steel plate Enamelled cast iron plate
Heat-up Fast, low thermal mass Slower, high thermal mass
Heat distribution Less even, stainless steel conducts heat poorly Even across the whole surface
Searing meat Fair, quicker to adjust Strong, the plate gives back its heat
Cleaning Water, steel wool, ice cubes fine on good plates Water and a cloth, never ice, no knocks
Usual thickness 3 to 6 mm Varies by maker (5 mm on Brasero models)
Weak spot Food sticks without fat, brown patina Enamel chips if knocked, weight
Brasero Silvia IIG Stainless 2 burners

€199.00

Price checked on 29/10/2026

For a stainless steel plate under €200.

See the offer on Amazon
Brasero Silvia IIG 3 burners Gun Metal

€269.00

Price checked on 29/10/2026

For a large enamelled cast iron plate for 10 people.

See the offer on Amazon

Stainless steel and enamelled cast iron: two ways to build a plate

The difference between a stainless steel and a cast iron griddle comes down to thermal mass: stainless steel stores little heat, cast iron stores a lot. According to the French consumer magazine Que Choisir, stainless steel plates are 3 to 6 mm thick, smooth, rinse clean with plain water and resist rust as long as their protective layer stays intact. Their lower thermal mass lets you change the cooking temperature faster. The French maker Roller Grill points out, however, that stainless steel is a poor heat conductor, which limits contact cooking quality.

Enamelled cast iron, along with enamelled steel, is the most common coating on consumer griddles. Que Choisir credits it with high thermal mass, even heat distribution, non-stick properties and little sensitivity to corrosion. Roller Grill recommends enamel for its cooking quality and easy cleaning.

Bare cast iron or enamelled cast iron

Bare cast iron is the original plancha material: very thick, it sears meat well, but it is heavy, food sticks until it is seasoned, and it rusts if you do not oil it. Roller Grill counts 15 to 20 minutes of preheating. Enamel covers the iron with a smooth layer that removes the need for seasoning and oiling, at the cost of being sensitive to knocks.

What about hard chrome and rolled steel?

Two other surfaces exist. Hard chrome, on plates 16 to 20 mm thick, is popular with professionals for its searing and its resistance to thermal shock, but it is expensive. Rolled or ground steel offers good value and lets you cut food on the plate, as long as you oil it after each clean.

Heat-up and heat distribution

Enamelled cast iron wins on heat distribution, stainless steel wins on responsiveness. A plate with high thermal mass takes longer to heat but keeps its temperature when cold food lands on it: that is what lets you sear red meat and get a proper Maillard crust without the plate collapsing. Stainless steel, thinner and less conductive, heats fast and cools fast: handy for switching from high heat to gentle heat for vegetables or fish.

Que Choisir adds that the result does not depend on the material alone: plate thickness, composition, build quality and distance from the burners matter just as much. A thick plate resists warping better, whether it is stainless steel or cast iron. That is why a 5 mm stainless steel plate, as Favex lists on its Silvia IIG Stainless, behaves better than thin sheet metal.

Cleaning and care: the real everyday difference

Stainless steel is the easiest plate to look after: scrape with a spatula, pour water on the still-hot plate, wipe with a sponge. Good stainless steel plates tolerate deglazing with ice cubes and steel wool. A brown patina may appear after the first cooks, which does not affect cooking according to Que Choisir.

Enamelled cast iron is nearly as easy: deglazing with water and a cloth is usually enough. Two rules make all the difference: no ice cubes or violent thermal shock, and no knocks from metal utensils that could crack the enamel. On good-quality enamel, steel wool is still fine.

For both materials, Que Choisir suggests white vinegar to remove smells between fish and meat, and a cold clean with soapy water or baking soda. Only bare cast iron and rolled steel need a thin coat of oil to prevent rust.

Durability, weight and warranty

On lifespan, the gap depends more on the maker's warranty than on the material. A stainless steel plate fears neither rust nor light scratches; an enamelled plate does not rust either, but a chip in the enamel cannot be repaired. By the sea, Que Choisir recommends a 304 stainless steel frame and a protective cover, because screws and edges rust first.

Warranties on the makers' spec sheets vary widely: 10 years on the Krampouz Samba's stainless steel plate, lifetime on the plate and burners of Le Marquier's La Petite Française, 2 years on the Silvia IIG Stainless and the Somagic. Cast iron is not always the heavier option: the Silvia IIG Stainless 2 burners weighs 23.6 kg according to Favex, La Petite Française in enamelled cast iron 14.4 kg according to Le Marquier.

Gas or electric: does the material change?

The fuel has little bearing on the stainless steel or cast iron choice: both materials are found on gas griddles. Indoor electric models more often use a PTFE non-stick coating, which handles around 250 °C on good-quality models according to Que Choisir.

How we compared

We looked at five gas griddles, two with a stainless steel plate and three with an enamelled cast iron plate, picked from the models cited by Que Choisir and Roller Grill and from the Krampouz, Le Marquier, Brasero by Favex and Somagic ranges. Criteria: plate material and thickness, power, cooking surface, warranty, place of manufacture. Specs come from the makers' pages, cross-checked with the Amazon listings; a missing or conflicting value is marked "n.c.". No model was tested hands-on. Prices checked on Amazon on 29/10/2026.

Model Plate Power Surface (cm) Warranty Price checked
Krampouz Samba gas Stainless steel, thickness n.c. 3,000 W 54 x 33 10 years (plate) €399.00 on 29/10/2026
Brasero Silvia IIG Stainless 2 burners Stainless steel 5 mm 5.3 kW 52 x 34 2 years €199.00 on 29/10/2026
Le Marquier La Petite Française Gaz 250 Enamelled cast iron 3,600 W 50 x 35 Lifetime €249.00 on 29/10/2026
Brasero Silvia IIG 3 burners Gun Metal Enamelled cast iron 5 mm 7.5 kW 67 x 34 n.c. €269.00 on 29/10/2026
Somagic Solia 200 Enamelled cast iron 4.25 kW 51.5 x 36.5 2 years €179.00 on 29/10/2026

The price shown on Amazon when you buy is the one that applies.

Stainless steel: Krampouz Samba and Brasero Silvia IIG Stainless

The Krampouz Samba is the most expensive model here for only 3,000 W, and its spec sheet does not give the plate thickness. On the plus side, it is designed and assembled in Brittany, its stainless steel plate carries a 10-year warranty and spare parts remain available for 15 years. It suits a small terrace, for about 6 people according to Krampouz. See the offer on Amazon

The Brasero Silvia IIG Stainless 2 burners only has a 2-year warranty and Amazon lists it as made in China. At €199.00 on 29/10/2026, it offers a 5 mm stainless steel plate, 5.3 kW and a grease tray with a clear gauge, for up to 8 people according to Favex. See the offer on Amazon

Enamelled cast iron: Le Marquier, Brasero and Somagic

Le Marquier's La Petite Française Gaz 250 tops out at 250 °C according to its spec sheet, and the number of people it serves is not stated. Its plate and burners carry a lifetime warranty, it holds the Origine France Garantie label and weighs 14.4 kg. See the offer on Amazon

The Brasero Silvia IIG 3 burners Gun Metal has a plate only 5 mm thick and Amazon lists it as made in China. Its 3 burners deliver 7.5 kW over 67 x 34 cm, enough to cook for 10. See the offer on Amazon

The Somagic Solia 200 comes without hose or regulator and has a 2-year warranty. It is the cheapest model here, with 4.25 kW on a plate with raised edges and 13 kg on the scale. See the offer on Amazon

To compare more models in this material, our enamelled cast iron gas griddle page reviews ten of them.

Our verdict

Choose stainless steel if you often cook fish, vegetables and shellfish, want quick cleaning without precautions, or keep the griddle by the sea: the Krampouz Samba for French manufacturing and its 10-year warranty, the Brasero Silvia IIG Stainless to stay under €200. Choose enamelled cast iron if you mostly sear meat and want steady, even heat: Le Marquier's La Petite Française for the lifetime warranty, the Somagic Solia 200 for the budget, the Silvia IIG 3 burners for large gatherings.

Brasero Silvia IIG Stainless 2 burners

€199.00

Price checked on 29/10/2026

For a stainless steel plate under €200.

See the offer on Amazon
Brasero Silvia IIG 3 burners Gun Metal

€269.00

Price checked on 29/10/2026

For a large enamelled cast iron plate for 10 people.

See the offer on Amazon

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between cast iron and enamelled cast iron?

Bare cast iron has no coating: it has to be seasoned and then oiled so food does not stick and it does not rust. Enamelled cast iron is covered with a smooth enamel layer that protects it from corrosion and makes it non-stick, but that layer does not like thermal shocks or knocks.

Does food stick more on stainless steel than on enamelled cast iron?

Yes, stainless steel lacks the non-stick properties of enamel. A drizzle of oil and a well-heated plate reduce sticking. The brown patina that appears after the first cooks does not affect cooking.

Can you put ice cubes on an enamelled cast iron griddle?

No. Que Choisir advises against violent thermal shocks on enamel: deglazing with water and a cloth is enough. Ice cubes are for good stainless steel and hard chrome plates.

Which is the best stainless steel griddle brand?

No brand wins on every criterion. Among the models we checked, Krampouz builds in France and guarantees its stainless steel plate for 10 years, while Brasero by Favex offers a 5 mm stainless steel plate at a lower price with a 2-year warranty.

Which griddle is best by the sea?

A stainless steel plate and frame, ideally 304 stainless steel, and a protective cover for storage: Que Choisir notes that screws and edges rust first in sea air.